AFL Spherical Desk Spherical 1 Does AFL Want a Concussion Substitute?
The AFL 2021 season begins Thursday night. Our consultants sort out a number of the burning questions forward of the primary spherical.
Does AFL Want A Concussion Substitute?
Rohan Connolly: I perceive the intention, however the delay of this concept makes it a form of anxious safety in opposition to the potential for authorized motion, quite than one thing utterly mentioned and deliberate. So it makes extra sense to suppose that this may be a broader substitute for severe damage. You need the system to be as simple to know and interpret as potential.
Jake Michaels: Name me cranky, however no, I do not like the thought of a concussion sub. Do not get me fallacious, I am all for making progress relating to participant well being and wellness, however I simply do not see how a concussion substitute will cut back the variety of concussions we see. within the sport. This won’t be the case. How about penalizing gamers A LOT extra severely for each head-up hit?
Matt Walsh: I believe Rohan hit that nail on the pinnacle a few lawsuit. That is one thing the AFL is deeply involved about, however I believe the rule has advantage. Let’s put the gamers on the ice for minor headshots if we have now a participant ready backstage. I would not name it a “ concussion sub ”, I’d name it a “ head subwoofer ” and I used it for the little ones too. Let’s not threat the well-being of the gamers once we know the injury that may happen.
Jarryd Barca: Concussion is a major problem in our sport and I completely respect the measures which might be taken, however subs generally are a no on my half. A alternative can’t be there for a selected function in my view. Does it additionally develop into too advantageous for a staff that loses a participant to a concussion to have one other recent pair of legs enjoying the remainder of a sport? Additionally, what number of occasions have groups misplaced gamers to match-ending accidents and gained once more? If submarines are launched, coaches should management how they use them.
What affect will the brand new AFL guidelines have on the sport?
RC: I think a good quantity. The primary indications are that the man-in-the-mark rule has actually inspired gamers to search for extra choices down the corridor. This may result in extra direct attacking soccer, but in addition to extra turnovers, which is able to result in extra unpredictable patterns of play. Likewise, rolling again the mark an extra 5 yards on kicks encourages defenders to go straight to the heart. And decreasing the commerce from 90 to 75 maybe passes the tipping level at which fatigue turns into extra of an element.
? How do you beat the Tigers?
❗ Our daring requires 2021
? Season forecast + the staff that may ‘make a Geelong 2007’
? Sub-discussion on concussions
☀️ All issues Matt Rowell
? Our large signature
– The ESPN Footy Podcast (@ESPNFootyPod) March 16, 2021
JM: Hope that is optimistic! Critically, I believe we’d see a rise in scores within the early rounds, however I do not think about it should take coaches lengthy to design sport plans to finish their opposition. In spite of everything, no AFL coach desires to be in a shootout each week! Till then, can we reserve our judgment till we have now seen at the very least three or 4 full rounds of soccer?
MW: I’ve stated it earlier than and I will say it once more, coaches don’t need groups to attain large in opposition to them. I lately spoke with quite a lot of captains about defensive ways and the brand new guidelines, and all of them stated their staff is engaged on easy methods to cease the kick within the lane. It might take just a few weeks, however the protection will dominate the perch once more. As for the buying and selling cap? Effectively, that is one much less spin per participant, per sport (form of!). I am unsure it should have a huge effect.
JB: We’ll see some monstrous total scores in video games this yr. Here is the affect: it should be too simple to attain. That’s till the coaches – and it will not take lengthy – to develop methods to quell their opposition and restrict their avenues to objective. Protection wins prime ministerial positions, in spite of everything.
Which coach is beginning the season underneath probably the most strain?
RC: I believe it should actually be Simon Goodwin in Melbourne. The Demons have been deeply disappointing in two seasons since coming into the highest 4. There was a disturbing disconnect between their skill to win balls in midfield and create scores, which makes you surprise about their construction. And there have been horrible psychological failures as nicely. I believe he has big issues in the event that they miss the eight once more this season.
JM: I will go a little bit left right here and say Chris Scott. Geelong seems to be everybody’s premier recommendation for 2021 and there is no doubt their roster has improved considerably with the additions of Jeremy Cameron, Shaun Higgins and Isaac Smith. Their prime minister’s window will not be open eternally, and a lean begin to the yr will undoubtedly have many individuals questioning Scott’s place. Even he’ll know.
MW: Contemplating Nathan Buckley’s final 12 months (COVID violations, exodus from the checklist because of mismanagement of the wage cap, involvement in Lumumba’s story), if he desires one other contract, his staff should play the ultimate. Will the Pies play within the finals? Possibly not. Would Buckley get one other gig as head coach? Possibly not, given this latest historical past.
JB: Oh, the immense strain to achieve success as an AFL coach … I believe Nathan Buckley, Simon Goodwin and Leon Cameron are in the identical boat, regardless of the variations of their respective contracts. It is a finale or a bust for all three.
What’s your one large daring name for the yr?
RC: Sydney to do the final eight. There are at present solely two groups on Sportsbet which have longer odds to play within the Finals, and I believe the Swans may actually make that ridiculous. They confirmed some very encouraging indicators in direction of the tip of final season, have a bunch of fast-emerging youngsters (eg, Justin McInerney), and have extra strings to their bow now, with or with out Lance Franklin. Do not say I did not warn you!
JM: I do not suppose the Prime Minister or the Brownlow medal winner might be too unpredictable in 2021, so I will go for an All-Australian choice from left area: the younger Dockers pistol, Andrew Brayshaw. He had a breakout yr in midfield in 2020 and I anticipate his fast enchancment to proceed this season. If he can discover a method to hit the scoreboard – he failed to attain a objective in 2020 – then I believe he definitely has an opportunity of successful his first All-Australian blazer.
MW: Folks and the AFL will hate “regular size” quarterbacks a lot that the AFL will revert to a shortened sport in 2022. We have seen 36-minute stanzas to this point this yr – too lengthy!
JB: I firmly consider that we’ll see a staff rating over 200 factors in a sport this yr, which would be the first time in a decade!